Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (2024)

Posted on - Last updated:

Jump to Recipe

Table of Contents hide

1Reliving Memories with an Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe

1.1Do you have a food that brings back such powerful memories?

1.2Have you tried Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy?

Reliving Memories with an Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe

Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (1)

When I was growing up, we lived next door to the sweetest lady. We all called her Grandma Della. She really was like a grandma to all nine of us crazy Nelson kids. It was such a shock to me to grow up and learn she wasn’t really my Grandma by relation. Just a great neighbor and family friend that all us kids adopted to be a grandma. And it wasn’t just our family that were her adopted Grandkids. She was known as Grandma Della by all the kids in our little community.

One of my favorite memories as a kid was always visiting Grandma Della. She always had the best stories to tell, and delicious treats! The one treat she was most known for in our entire community was her old fashioned Vinegar taffy. I’m telling you this vinegar taffy recipe was famous!

Every Halloween kids would visit her house first just for the Vinegar Taffy. And every Christmas we’d get a plate full of these coveted goodies!

Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (2)

Grandma Della passed away a number of years ago. She has been greatly missed. She left behind such an amazing legacy with her kindness, love and compassion. It is amazing how one can touch so many and make such a powerful impact on their lives. And she was definitely one of those women who impacted so many for good.

It amazes me how a simple flavor can bring back a flood of memories. The last time I was home visiting, I went through my Mom’s recipe cupboards to find some of my favorite recipes from growing up and I stumbled upon Grandma Della’s Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy recipe. I knew instantly I had to bring this tradition to my family.

So we got started over Christmas Holiday making the Vinegar Taffy. The recipe is quite simple and so easy to get ready.

Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (3)

Prepare the sugar, cream of tartar, vinegar and salt in a sauce pan and bring to a boil. Boil until it reaches the hard ball stage (250 degrees F). Remove from the heat and then add in the butter.

Then you will spray a dish with a little coconut oil or lightly grease it. Just so it doesn’t stick to the plate/dish. And pour in the taffy mixture. And then allow it to cool until you can manipulate it with your hands without it burning.

Next is the part that begins to bring back the memories. The taffy pulling!

Wash your hands well. Then lightly butter them to prevent the taffy from sticking.

I set up a station for each kid and pulled off a smaller section of the taffy for them each to pull.

Then you start pulling the taffy.

Pull fromthe center out. Then put the ends together and pull from the enter out again.

Just keep pulling. Just keep Pulling (I think you can think up a song for this phrase right?)

Pull the taffy until it is light in color and stiff. The whiter the better. This could take anywhere from 15 minutes to 60 minutes depending on how many people you have pulling the taffy and how much you each are working with.

How taffy begins #candy #Christmas #baking #treats #traditions

A photo posted by Amber Edwards (@jadelouisedesigns) on

This was a great activity with the kids, as I gave each one their own little section to pull. As we pulled we talked and I told them stories about Grandma Della and the history of the Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy and what it has meant to our family.

Next shape into a nice long rope. And cut with greased scissors into 1″ pieces.

Hmmm old fashioned vinegar taffy! Brings back great memories. #taffy #oldfashioned #recipe #Christmas #christmastreats

A photo posted by Amber Edwards (@jadelouisedesigns) on

Then wrap up in wax paper.

Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (4)

As we pulled, the memories of sitting in Grandma Della’s kitchen helping her to pull taffy as she told stories of when she was a little girl came flooding back to me in such a rush. I could remember the smells, the sounds, the colors. I could remember the love emanating from Grandma Della.

And then when I tasted my first bite of Grandma Della’s Vinegar Taffy, it was like I was transported back in time. It’s amazing what a little flavor associated with great memories can do.

And while mine doesn’t look as beautiful as Grandma Della’s vinegar taffy did (she has years more practice getting it to look just right) the flavor was exactly the same! And I may have been a bit emotional for the duration. But it was so worth it, having that little piece of Grandma Della back in my life again.

Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (5)

I think this will definitely be a new family tradition; to make Grandma Della’s Vinegar Taffy near Christmas to share with friends and family and build our own memories around for my own kids. And it will give me a great time to remember back on such an amazing woman who had such a powerful impact on my life.

Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (6)

Do you have a food that brings back such powerful memories?

Have you tried Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy?


Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe

Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (7)

An old recipe passed down the generations for a family favorite Old fashioned Vinegar Taffy candy.

Prep Time5 minutes

Cook Time10 minutes

Total Time15 minutes


  • 2 cups sugar
  • 1/8 teaspoon cream of tartar
  • 1/2 cup White distilled vinegar (could substitute apple cider if needed)
  • pinch of salt
  • 2 Tablespoons butter ( Or a diary free butter substitute if you need dairy free)


  1. Combine all ingredients except butter in a pan.
  2. Bring to boil
  3. Boil until it reaches the hard ball stage (~250 degrees f)
  4. Remove from heat and add butter
  5. Lightly Grease a platter
  6. Pour the Taffy onto the platter and allow to cool until you can handle without burning your hands.
  7. Wash your hands
  8. Apply a thin layer of butter to your hands
  9. Begin to pull the taffy
  10. Pull until it is light in color and stiff (15-60 minutes)
  11. Roll into a rope
  12. Cut into 1" pieces
  13. Wrap in wax paper squares
Old Fashioned Vinegar Taffy Recipe (2024)


What's the difference between salt water taffy and regular taffy? ›

There was little or no salt added to the candy over 100 years ago or now. Manufacturers of the candy in seaside towns capitalize on the name of salt water taffy, but there is truly no difference between salt water and regular taffy.

What's the difference between nougat and taffy? ›

Although not closely “genetically” related to nougat or torrón, taffy recipes have a lot in common with the chewy versions of those sweets. The big difference: taffy is not (normally) aerated and set with egg whites, and doesn't (normally) have additions like nuts or dried fruit.

What is the difference between toffee and taffy? ›

Is toffee the same as taffy? Taffy is in no way, shape, or form toffee. Taffy describes chewy fruit candies, whereas toffee is closer to caramel.

Why is my taffy so hard? ›

If our taffy feels hard, it is most likely because it is cold; try holding the taffy snugly in the palm of your hand for a few moments, the warmth should soften it right up!

What is taffy called in England? ›

In the United Kingdom, taffy pieces are known as "chewy sweets", "chews" or "fruit chews"—the term "taffy" is not widely used. Popular brands of chew include Chewits and Starburst.

Is Laffy taffy and salt water taffy the same? ›

Every brand will have its own special recipe, but taffy and salt water taffy are often considered to be the same candy, with one key difference—the design. While traditional taffy can come in all shapes and sizes, salt water taffy has a signature look.

What is yellow and green taffy? ›

Pineapple Flavored Saltwater Taffies

Old fashioned, individually wrapped, pineapple flavored gourmet salt water taffies in green and yellow colors.

Are Starburst considered taffy? ›

Starburst (originally known as Opal Fruits) is the brand name of a box-shaped, fruit-flavoured soft taffy candy manufactured by The Wrigley Company, which is a subsidiary of Mars, Incorporated.

Is nougat just marshmallow? ›

Nougat is a confection made with sugar or honey that's cooked and then whipped with egg whites to aerate it. It often contains almonds or other nuts, candied fruits and chocolate, although it can be left plain. Nougat can be soft and tender like marshmallow but is more often dense and very chewy.

Are Tootsie Rolls just taffy? ›

Tootsie Roll (/ˈtʊtsi/) is a chocolate-flavored candy that has been manufactured in the United States since 1907. The candy has qualities similar to both caramels and taffy without being exactly either confection. The manufacturer, Tootsie Roll Industries, is based in Chicago, Illinois.

What is black taffy candy? ›

Today it is called Black Taffy but it was originally called Black Jack Taffy and sometimes Black Jacks or Blackjack Kisses. It is a salt-water sized taffy with a swirl of licorice in the center. It combines the flavor of anise and licorice.

Are airheads taffy? ›

Airheads is an American brand of the taffy candy owned by the Italian-Dutch company Perfetti Van Melle. They were created on August 7, 1985, by Steve Bruner. Airheads are available nationwide in the United States and Canada where the candy is available in 16 different flavors.

What does glycerin do for taffy? ›

In this taffy recipe, glycerin helps give the candy a soft, creamy consistency. Glycerin can be found in many drugstores, as well as some supermarkets and craft stores in the baking supplies section, or in cake-decorating stores.

How can you tell if taffy is stale? ›

If it becomes too hard to consume, is overly sticky, or has a foul odor, chances are your taffy has gone bad. To prevent this from happening, you can store your taffy candy in a cool, dry area. Saltwater taffy can last for up to one month in the fridge.

What happens when you eat too much taffy? ›

Consuming a lot of high-fat, high-sugar candies can contribute to weight gain and the development of illnesses including obesity and Type 2 diabetes in the long run. Furthermore, germs in your mouth thrive on sugar, which can lead to tooth damage and cavities if oral care is neglected after taffy-eating.

Are you supposed to chew salt water taffy? ›

There really is no wrong way to eat a piece of taffy. But we give super props to anyone that can keep it in their mouth without eating it for longer than it takes to chew it.

What makes taffy salt water taffy? ›

Saltwater taffy ingredients are fairly simple. The candy is made from sugar, cornstarch, corn syrup, glycerine, butter, water, and salt. Other saltwater taffy ingredients can include food coloring and natural or artificial flavorings, especially fruit flavors.

Why is salt water taffy only sold at the beach? ›

Though it contains no saltwater, taffy—and fudge, its sister seaside treat—may benefit from being made in a beach climate. Perhaps the salty air simply gives people a hankering for something sweet; it's also possible that the candies' decelerated drying and oxidation in humid air give them a unique “coastal” flavor.

Is all taffy made with salt water? ›

How Is Taffy Made? While there are various taffy-making formulas, the basic ingredients consist of sugar, corn syrup, cornstarch, salt, water (but not salt water!), butter, glycerine, food coloring and natural or artificial flavors.


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Trent Wehner

Last Updated:

Views: 6121

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Trent Wehner

Birthday: 1993-03-14

Address: 872 Kevin Squares, New Codyville, AK 01785-0416

Phone: +18698800304764

Job: Senior Farming Developer

Hobby: Paintball, Calligraphy, Hunting, Flying disc, Lapidary, Rafting, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Trent Wehner, I am a talented, brainy, zealous, light, funny, gleaming, attractive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.